go logo go
 
article photo
article photo
article photo
article photo
Some unusual toppings add interest to pizzas at Extreme Pizza in Miracle Hills, a San Francisco-based chain's first Omaha location. The Baja 1000 shown here includes black beans and salsa, grilled chicken or green chilies, black olives, red onions, tomatoes, jalapenos, cilantro and cheddar cheese.(Kent Sievers/THE WORLD-HERALD)
article photo
Nick Gordon mans the phone at Extreme Pizza, a franchise of the national chain that he and his mom, Lisa Gordon, opened in December.(Kent Sievers/THE WORLD-HERALD)
article photo
Black beans and salsa enliven the Baja 1000 pizza at Extreme Pizza.(Kent Sievers/THE WORLD-HERALD)


DINING REVIEW

Toppings give Extreme Pizza an edge

« Go

Two revelations from recent visits to Extreme Pizza:

Played loudly enough at mealtime, certain Alice in Chains tunes can make you seriously consider base-jumping.

Related News

EXTREME PIZZA

Where: 741 N. 114th St.
Prices: $8 to $15 per person
Hours: 11 a.m. to 11 p.m. Sundays through Thursdays; and 11 a.m. to midnight Fridays and Saturdays.
Information: 884-1115 or extremepizza.com

Find it:

View Larger Map

* * *

Extreme Pizza Omaha menu

World-Herald reviewing guidelines

Map of Nichole Aksamit's restaurant reviews

For reader reviews and more about the restaurant, see "Related" links at top right.

* * *

How was your meal?
The World-Herald bases restaurant reviews on a variety of fare from two or more unannounced visits. But eateries change frequently. Our experience may differ from yours. That's why we screen and post reader comments online with reviews. Please send an e-mail about your dining experience at this eatery to nichole.aksamit@owh.com or elizabeth.freeman@owh.com.
For proper attribution, please include your first and last names and the city in which you live.

And toasted walnuts are extremely good on pizza.

More on both later. First, what's Extreme Pizza?

Opened in December in a narrow strip mall bay near Clancy's Pub in Miracle Hills, it's the first Omaha location of a San Francisco-based gourmet pizza chain with an extreme sports theme.

A surfboard dangles from the ceiling. Skateboards and snowboards hug the walls above the red-topped tables in the long hallway that constitutes most of the dining room. Snowboarding competitions, BMX bike races and other sporting events play on mounted TVs.

The offerings, most of them listed on big boards above the register, are focused: A few sandwiches, salads and calzones. Limited wine, beer and cocktails. Bar-type add-ons such as Buffalo wings, garlic twists and vendor-supplied cheesecake. And the main event: dine-in, delivery and take-and-bake pizzas with some interesting toppings (black beans and salsa, Portuguese sausage, mandarin oranges, nuts), clever names (the hummus-topped Peace in the Middle East, say, or the cheeseless White Out) and near-equal selections for meat-lovers and vegetarians.

The pizzas are available in 8-, 12-, 14- and 18-inch rounds ranging from about $5 to $24, depending on your options (more than 40 toppings, not including four house-made sauces). Each day, two of the signature pizzas (one meat and one vegetarian) are also available by the slice. White and whole-wheat crusts are made on-site and served medium-thick unless you ask for something thinner or thicker. There's also a gluten-free version, made on 12-inch crusts provided by an outside outfit called Still Riding.

Now about those walnuts: The clear standout of all the pizzas I tried was the Holy Cow, a meatless number topped with fontina, Swiss, Gorgonzola, mozzarella, toasted walnuts and sage. On our server's recommendation, I had it with tomato sauce and a wheat crust. The flavorful crust had a crisp bottom, a chewy top and a puffed edge freckled with cornmeal. The sage was restrained, the quartet of cheeses was harmonious, and the oven-toasted walnuts were as meaty and resounding as sausage.

When I raved about that satisfying pizza later, co-owner Lisa Gordon agreed. “A lot of these pizzas, you don't even realize they don't have meat.”

For die-hard carnivores, there was the Everest: pepperoni, meatball slices, Canadian bacon, mozzarella and cheddar with a fresh-tasting tomato sauce on a white crust that was every bit as chewy and cornmeal-crisped as the wheat. Happily, despite all the good stuff on top, it was rich without being overly greasy.

Another I'd have again is the Aveiro, named for a city in Portugal and topped with mozzarella, pepperoncini, roasted red pepper, bacon and slices of linguica, a garlic-laced Portuguese sausage. One quibble: It lacked the intended fresh cilantro.

From the Monster Sub section, a sandwich dubbed the Crux was tasty: tender shredded pork, sweet barbecue sauce, red onions and melted cheddar on a long, toasted ciabatta bun, pressed flat and cut diagonally. It, too, was missing its cilantro, and it looked more like a pressed panini than the giant U-boat of a sandwich the menu suggested.

Gordon said they've been working on making sure the right herbs are included with the right dishes and that she is still searching for a local version of the bread the chain uses elsewhere for its sandwiches: a roughly 8-inch by 3.5-inch hoagie roll that better lives up to the “monster sub” name.

Boneless (think chicken nugget) and standard chicken wings were tossed in our choice of a sweet barbecue, a spicy Buffalo or a seriously scorching Thai pepper sauce. Available by the half or whole dozen, they came with ranch or blue cheese dressing and a few sticks of celery and carrot to help put out the fire. If wings are your thing, you'd do well to get them during happy hour (5 p.m. to 7 p.m. nightly), when they go for half price.

A few duds: A Caesar side salad had a thick dressing, gritty and chalky with ground cheese; rock-hard croutons; and Romaine of varying freshness (some crisp and lovely, some browning at the edges). A fun-to-say Mr. Pestato Head pizza had a flavorful pesto sauce, melted mozzarella and red onion, but it stumbled with undercooked slices of red-skinned potato and crashed with the omission of three promised ingredients: fresh basil, dried oregano and feta cheese. And the Extremely Twisted Sticks were timid cradles of pizza dough with Fontina and Swiss cheese but none of the garlic punch the menu led me to expect. Gordon said the eatery may have erred on the cautious side when seasoning those because the garlic it uses is so potent.

One minor bummer: I missed out on dessert. They were out of the New York cheesecake, and the only other sweet (a large house-made chocolate chip cookie) didn't make it into a to-go order.

Gordon said diners generally order and pay at the counter, take a number and a seat and get their own drink, even if they're dining in. But it was pretty slow when we were there, and a friendly gal behind the counter handed us a menu, took our order at the table and even brought us our drinks.

Though she and other staffers were pleasant and inviting, the music was not. A loud, fast-tempo mix of whiny pop and grating grunge (including the aforementioned Alice in Chains) had me contemplating jumping off a building (with parachute, of course, in keeping with the extreme theme). It's why I opted for takeout on a return visit.

Asked about the music later, Gordon said she, too, found it annoying: “Every time I walk in in the morning, I say: ‘Why is it so loud?'”

She assured me that she and her staff are dialing down the tunes, dialing up the flavor and fine-tuning order accuracy as they settle in to their second month in business and their first Super Bowl weekend in Omaha.

I say: Better stock up on walnuts.

Contact the writer:

444-1069, nichole.aksamit@owh.com


Contact the Omaha World-Herald newsroom


Copyright ©2012 Omaha World-Herald®. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, displayed or redistributed for any purpose without permission from the Omaha World-Herald.

FEATURED STORIES

MUSIC
New Edition cancels Omaha concert
New Edition cancels Omaha concert

Tickets will be refunded. The show will not be rescheduled.

 
MUSIC
Best Coast gives surf rock modern twist
Best Coast gives surf rock modern twist

Whether it's a bright, sunny afternoon or freezing, snowy winter morning, Best Coast will transport...

 
ARTS
Follow the Yellow Brick Road to museum full of fun
Follow the Yellow Brick Road to museum full of fun

Kids will be able to follow the Yellow Brick Road to the fabulous Emerald City, with lots of stops...

   
Search

On tap Thursday, May. 24

Son Volt at The Waiting Room.

Click for more events »

Register an event »

Latest in the Blogs
Omavore China street style
Filed by Sarah Baker Hansen
May 24 at 11:24 am
Omavore The real Kung Pao Chicken
Filed by Sarah Baker Hansen
May 23 at 2:02 pm
Rock Candy Guest List: Whispertown
Filed by Kevin Coffey
May 23 at 12:15 am
Rock Candy Nickelback still delivering the same
Filed by Kevin Coffey
May 22 at 11:01 pm
Rock Candy Deer Tick smashes through 23 songs at the Waiting Room
Filed by Kevin Coffey
May 21 at 3:49 pm
Jump to a blog:
Movies Opening this week

Movie showtimes and theater listings

Men in Black III - PG-13

Chernobyl Diaries - R

Monsieur Lazhar - PG-13 (exclusively at Film Streams)







Tonight in Prime Time
 

GO GET A COPY! // find a location near you to pick up a magazine

go magazine is Omaha's best weekly source of local entertainment news and information. It's got everything you expected — previews and analysis, complete calendar listing of local events, tips and tricks for living well around town.


Pick one up at a rack near you. or find GO in Thursday's World-Herald.

© 2012 Omaha World-Herald. All rights reserved