LINCOLN — Slaying suspect Aubrey Trail kept about 56 Beanie Babies, several toy trucks, a lion rug and “shackles” in his apartment in Wilber, Nebraska, and his defense attorney wants to look over the items before they are destroyed.
On Wednesday, Trail’s attorney, Ben Murray of Hebron, filed two motions in court, asking a judge to allow him to inspect the apartment and the belongings left behind by Trail and his roommate, Bailey Boswell, and to preserve them for testing by the defense team.
The motions came in response to a “right to reclaim abandoned property” notice sent by the apartment’s owner last week to Trail, who is jailed in Saline County. Trail was notified that the toys, antiques and other belongings would be “kept, sold or destroyed” unless the property is picked up and a $2,875 storage bill is paid by Tuesday.
“Preservation of the scene and evidence contained within it is vital and material to the defendant’s defense,” Murray stated in his motion, citing a judge’s recent order granting defense attorneys the right to obtain all evidence collected in the case.
The defense attorney said destruction of the property would be a sign of “bad faith” and would prevent Trail’s lawyers from doing their own crime-scene tests on the items.
Trail’s apartment, which is next to Wilber-Clatonia High School, had been under the control of law enforcement officials until recently, when it was turned over to the apartment’s owner. The landlord, Alan Koll, declined comment when contacted Wednesday.
Trail, 51, and Boswell, 24, are each charged with first-degree murder and improper disposal of a body in connection with the death of Sydney Loofe, a Lincoln store clerk who disappeared after arranging a date on Tinder with Boswell. Loofe’s dismembered body was found Dec. 4 and 5 in a rural area about 60 miles west of Wilber.
Trail was well-known to area antique dealers, who said he liked to trade in antique toys. Among the possessions left behind were cast-iron toys, toy trucks, toy soldiers, wind-up toys and an “1853 Jewish Bible.” Most of the other items, aside from the shackles, were routine household items and clothing.
Trail has claimed in calls to the media that Loofe was accidentally strangled with an electrical cord as she participated, voluntarily, in a sexual fantasy. The state, by charging Trail with first-degree murder, is alleging that the act was premeditated and intentional.
The shackles left behind were not described.
1 of 30
Omaha crews replant Memorial Park grass where swastika was found
Omaha crews replanted Memorial Park grass where a swastika was found. Read more
Pregnant woman shot in buttocks, men assaulted and robbed in Lincoln after meetings set up online
A pregnant woman was shot in the buttocks, one man was assaulted and another was robbed in Lincoln after online meetings went awry. Read more
Truck driver in 2016 Interstate 80 crash that killed 6 sentenced to 180 days in jail
A truck driver in a 2016 Interstate 80 crash that killed 6 was sentenced to 180 days in jail. Read more
Omaha robbery victim says only reason he's alive is because gunmen 'missed'
An Omaha robbery victim says only reason he's alive is because the gunmen "missed." Read more
Pot busts: Nebraska State Patrol seizes 168 pounds of marijuana in separate traffic stops near Giltner
The Nebraska State Patrol seized 168 pounds of marijuana in separate traffic stops near Giltner. Read more
Linked by his DNA, Omahan faces charges of raping four women over 12 years
A 54-year-old man faces three additional rape charges after officials say his DNA connected him to attacks on three different women years ago. Read more
Anthony Garcia's lawyers point to suicidal episodes as proof mental illness drove him to kill
JUNE 15: Anthony Garcia’s attorneys tried to establish that mental illness — fueled by his failure to live up to his parents’ expectations that he become a doctor — drove Garcia to four murders. The arguments came as the lawyers seek to keep Garcia from receiving the death penalty. READ MORE.
A year after a mentally ill man died in Omaha police custody, department beefs up training
JUNE 6: Numerous changes have been made at the Omaha Police Department in the year since the in-custody death of Zachary Bearheels, who was shocked with a Taser a dozen times. Bearheels, a Native American, was bipolar and schizophrenic. READ MORE.
20-year-old killed near Old Market was innocent bystander caught in gangs' crossfire, chief says
JUNE 5: The scene in downtown Omaha on Saturday night could have come straight out of a gangster movie. Rival gangs came upon each other on the Farnam Street sidewalk along Gene Leahy Mall, and someone from each gang started to fire. Jasmine Harris, 20, was fatally shot, seven others were injured and vehicles along Farnam Street were sprayed with bullets. READ MORE.
Man who sent prostitutes to strip on neighbor's porch sentenced for child porn
JUNE 19: A west Omaha man who sent prostitutes to strip on his neighbor’s porch was sentenced Monday to six years in prison for possessing child pornography. READ MORE.
17-year-old arrested as family mourns mother of two shot in Walmart parking lot
APRIL 20: Kayviaun Nelson was shot at the Irvington Walmart Supercenter at 6304 N. 99th St. She had been involved in a dispute elsewhere in Omaha and “it came to a head” in the Walmart lot. Two have been arrested in connection with her death. READ MORE.
Omahan to serve up to 20 years for ‘catfishing’ robberies after judge ignores probation recommendation
MAY 22: The Omaha man — 19 when he committed his crimes — had just told a judge that his life hit a turning point after he had sat in jail for the past seven months, thinking about his crime of helping another teen use an online dating service to lure seven men to be robbed. Then Judge Mark Ashford pronounced his sentence: 24 to 40 years in prison. READ MORE.
Prosecutors: Inmates used code words in thinly veiled attempt to bribe juror in murder trial
JUNE 22: A half-dozen people were involved in the half-baked scheme to bribe a juror who would help decide the fate of a double-murder defendant, Douglas County prosecutors say. READ MORE.
Omaha man is sentenced to life in prison for 2007 slaying of his aunt
MAY 1: In a cold case that lasted 10 years from crime to conviction, it took just 10 minutes for Douglas County District Judge Thomas Otepka to sentence Charles Simmer, 34, to a life term for the Nov. 3, 2007, slaying of his aunt. READ MORE.
Father defiant as he gets 10-20 years in prison for shaking 7-week-old baby
APRIL 26: Jacob Ford contended that he dropped his baby daughter and she hit her head on a crib railing and the floor. But prosecutors argued — and a judge agreed — that shaking and slamming were the causes of the massive brain damage that 7-week-old Skyler suffered. READ MORE.
Former teacher sentenced to 55 to 85 years in prison for repeated sexual assault of boy
APRIL 20: Judge Shelly Stratman estimated, conservatively, that the then-9-year-old boy was sexually assaulted about 52 times by a man he considered a father figure. It would have been easier to stay silent. But he spoke up. “He’s a very brave young man,” said Stratman. READ MORE.
'I just enjoy killing. Simple as that.' Quotes from airman's journal shared at sentencing in Offutt slaying
APRIL 11: “I just enjoy killing. Simple as that.” In the days after he strangled an acquaintance, Airman 1st Class Rhianda Dillard, Wilsey poured out his thoughts, and his murderous ambitions, in the handwritten pages of his journal. READ MORE.
22-year-old Omaha woman pleads guilty to motor vehicle homicide in death of 15-year-old girl
APRIL 9: A woman accused of driving drunk and causing a crash that killed a girl and injured the girl’s mother pleaded guilty to motor vehicle homicide and drunken driving/causing serious bodily injury. READ MORE.
Ex-Creighton student gets jail, probation for slashing woman's neck with knife
JUNE 21: In one swipe, Christopher Wheeler forever changed Teresa Spagna’s life — leaving a “big scar” across her throat, and her psyche. Judge Shelly Stratman sentenced Wheeler to 30 days in jail, followed by five years of probation. Wheeler, who had no record, had faced up to 20 years in prison. READ MORE.
Survivors rejoice as serial rapist is sentenced to 160 to 200 years in prison
JUNE 5: Brandon Weathers is sentenced to 160-200 years in prison. For the vicious torture and rapes of four women in 2002 and 2004. For violating the sanctity of their homes, their bodies and their sense of security. For defying the law — with an assist from state prison officials — by refusing to submit a DNA sample. READ MORE.
Man sentenced for 2016 slaying, but Omaha gangs' turf war rages on
MARCH 2: A judge had just lamented the turf war that claimed the life of 22-year-old Terrance Gunn. Then the feud spilled onto the judge’s turf. READ MORE.
Omaha man convicted of 3 counts of first-degree murder in July 2012 slayings
MARCH 1: An Omaha man was convicted Thursday of three counts of first-degree murder and weapon use in the July 2012 deaths of a methamphetamine dealer and his teenage sons. READ MORE.
Driver on drugs gets 8 to 12 years in prison for Omaha crashes that almost killed 4-year-old, elderly man
MARCH 1: Judge Shelly Stratman had sentenced defendants for horrible fatal crashes. Never had she seen a wreck where everyone survived but had such wildly different views of the crash’s impact. READ MORE.
Man convicted of arson and fatally stabbing girlfriend's uncle gets 100 years in prison
FEB. 28: Every morning, Steven Edwards would text a friend 20 years his senior to make sure he was OK. Edwards also checked on homeless Native Americans and let people stay in his apartment, although he himself had little to spare. Amid his kindness, he was fatally stabbed and set on fire by his niece’s boyfriend, whom he let stay under his roof. READ MORE.
Former jailer sentenced to prison after helping killer in love triangle
FEB. 21: A former Douglas County jailer at the center of a love-triangle killing will see the inside of a correctional facility from a new perspective. READ MORE.
Ex-teacher, coach sentenced to 25-30 years in prison after years-long relationship with teen girl
FEB. 9: The now-17-year-old victim gave an ultimatum to Judge Duane Dougherty: Impose a sentence of 52 years. “If you give him anything less than (that), you are basically saying that you don’t care if it happens again,” the girl said. “You’re putting another person at risk of having to go through what I’ve gone through. And nobody should have to go through what I’ve gone through.” READ MORE.
Prosecutor plans to appeal ex-Omaha fire captain's sexual assault sentence
MARCH 10: Three girls who looked to Lee Dunbar as a father were, instead, sexually assaulted by him. A jury decided as much in January. On Friday, Douglas County District Judge Marlon Polk sentenced Dunbar, a 67-year-old retired Omaha fire captain, to the minimum sentence of 15 years on each of the five first-degree sexual assault counts he had been convicted of. READ MORE.
Omaha gang member sentenced to life in prison for April 2016 fatal shooting
JAN. 23: A gang member prosecutors describe as a “menace” was sentenced to life in prison for firing 10 shots at a rival gang member in the middle of the day — and instead killing Barbara Williams, 55, a grandma who had been chatting on a stoop. READ MORE.
Man accused of shooting Army sergeant admitted to the crime, prosecutor says
JAN. 18: A man accused of fatally shooting an Army sergeant outside a bar stole his necklaces and later admitted to the shooting, a prosecutor said. Kyle LeFlore, 27, was shot in the chest at close range and died soon after being rushed to the hospital early Jan. 6. READ MORE.